L.A. Rollins – The Myth of Natural Rights

First published in The Pragmatist: A Utilitarian Approach, Vol. 2, No. 1, September 1984

Reviewed by Jorge Amador

I heartily endorse this book. Without beating around the bush, I will state that Lou Rollins’ brief work is packed with enough analytical insight to send proponents of natural-law theory into hiding.

My first encounter with The Myth of Natural Rights was through another review in The Hawaii Libertarian earlier this year. As soon as I read its title and learned what it was about,  I knew I wanted to see this book very badly. It was gratifying to discover another individual — without prodding by, or even apparent knowledge of, The Pragmatist — engaging in the same myth-shattering activity that The Pragmatist set out to do. This was particularly exciting because, in the history of scientific progress, this sort of spontaneous parallel independent research has been an indicator of the emergence of an important new development in a field study, presaging major changes in that field’s body of knowledge.

Once I started reading it, the book did not disappoint me. In a few dozen very readable pages laden with humor and biting sarcasm, the author manages to dissect and refute the moral systems of such prominent theoreticians as Ayn Rand, Tibor Machan, and Murray Rothbard as well as other, less-known advocates of what Rollins refers to as “natural-rights mythologizing.”

“In my view, natural law and natural rights are human inventions (not discoveries) intended to further the interests of the inventors” (p. 3). Quoting George Smith, Rollins notes that “natural law” or “natural rights” have been used by various philosophers to propose such disparate and contradictory theories as oligarchy, theocracy, feudalism, and socialism. Citing other sources, we find that natural law has been used to defend slavery, genocide, censorship, and a right to medical care and “a decent livelihood.”

Particularly ironic is the treatment of the supposed champion of the virtues of selfishness, Ayn Rand. We find that Rand’s “right to life,” which in her moral system forms the basis for all other rights, in the end must logically lead to a rejection of any action that will promote human life.

Utilizing his own insights and liberal doses of citations from other writers, Rollins finds holes, contradictions, absurdities, and vagueness in the written expositions of numerous natural-rights advocates. A recurrent theme is his observation that whereas natural-rights theorists posit that “man’s rights” stem from his requirement for survival, they are uniformly — and inconsistently within their systems — unwilling to grant the same rights to animal and plant life. “Rothbard’s argument,” for instance, “bases ‘human rights’ on human survival needs, which raises the question: Why don’t the survival needs of all other organisms generate ‘rights’ for these organisms? After all, they need freedom from violent interference with their survival activities as much as men do” (p.29).

Rollins describes himself as an “amoralist” and an “egoist.” He could also be described as delightfully empirical. Referring to “natural rights” as “fake or metaphorical rights,” Rollins notes the frequent use of metaphor in natural-rights discussion, like “moral philosophical barriers” against state oppression. But a ‘moral philosophical barrier” is merely a metaphorical barrier, and it will no more prevent the State’s encroachment upon ‘Society’ than a moral philosophical shield will stop a physical arrow from piercing your body” (p.2).

So it is, too, with the notion of “duty,” which natural-rights theorists slip into their discussions as that which others “ought” to do in order that rights not be violated. “Duty” is used in the same sense as “obligation,” which has the Latin root for “tying” — as Rollins quotes P.H. Nowel-Smith, “an obvious metaphor for coercion.” Thus duty is a matter of metaphorical or fake coercion. If you want someone to do something which he has no personal reason for doing, but you are unable or unwilling (perhaps afraid) to use real coercion to get him to do it, then you can try to get him to do it by means of metaphorical or fake coercion. You can tell him it’s his duty to do it.”

The Myth Of Natural Rights is an important libertarian work for both theorists and practitioners. It can serve several useful purposes. It can liberate libertarians from morality and the outreach burden of explaining to nonlibertarian moralists why libertarian moralizing is “better” than their present moralizing. It arms libertarians with analytical techniques and tools that can be applied to dismantle other, non-libertarian moralities. Finally, it can free libertarians and others from the shackles of moral “duty,” enhancing everyone’s potential for happiness and pleasure.

48 Responses to L.A. Rollins – The Myth of Natural Rights

  1. Pingback: FIFA 16 News

  2. Pingback: Wholesale 68205a Oakley Sunglasses ID8210222

  3. Pingback: cheap fifa 17 coins

  4. Pingback: UPAlbion.com

  5. Pingback: mens nike kd 8 ep basketball shoes black univeristy red white

  6. Pingback: adidas copa mundial firm ground soccer shoes dark blue red

  7. Pingback: nike free 3.0 v5 dark womens charcoal green glow summit white

  8. Pingback: womens nike air max bwh shoes white gold pink

  9. Pingback: christian louboutin zipito 120 peep toe ankle boots blue red bottom shoes

  10. Pingback: packers 80 donald driver white super bowl xlv stitched nfl jersey 813

  11. Pingback: beats by dre sale studio diamond new silver headphones

  12. Pingback: air jordan 4 for women 069

  13. Pingback: mori lee 6784 lace and organza sash and beading wedding dress

  14. Pingback: uk 4qypbgxr salomon uk fell raiser black grey red shoes

  15. Pingback: boys nike air force 1 mid preschool white white uk

  16. Pingback: nike air force 1 mid 07 womens shoe haystack

  17. Pingback: cheap NBA 2K17 MT

  18. Pingback: nike free run 3 v4 grey mens

  19. Pingback: nike air max hyperfly superme sneakers for men in 73266

  20. Pingback: nike free run 2 running shoes tumbled grey vivid grape to womens

  21. Pingback: air max 2011 netty womens breathable running shoes purple white gray fashion sale

  22. Pingback: nike kobe 9 low noir gris rouge

  23. Pingback: xm54tc98eyv54c6eny68v9ec5

  24. Pingback: xmzw54tdny45ty85fkte5f4yxwex

  25. Pingback: cmwetcmurmt5y7etmssdgdfg

  26. Pingback: The Best Basketball Shoes

  27. Pingback: x3m8cn7wetsxnwdb4cgsdf

  28. Pingback: txm657b8xm5ecntx5ctsxerfgert

  29. Pingback: xt3cm85w7tvwhwxmtcne7t5xem4cegxf

  30. Pingback: http://testbotping1.com/test-1.php

  31. Pingback: http://imgur.com/gallery/eQGBS

  32. Pingback: http://imgur.com/gallery/ljP8S

  33. Pingback: https://www.behance.net/gallery/47758611/Ganzer-xXx-Die-Rueckkehr-des-Xander-Cage-Film-Stream

  34. Pingback: https://www.behance.net/gallery/47758831/Ganzer-xXx-Die-Rueckkehr-des-Xander-Cage-Film-Deutsch

  35. Pingback: https://www.behance.net/gallery/47759731/HDHQ-Ganzer-Verborgene-Schoenheit-Film-Stream-Deutsch

  36. Pingback: https://www.behance.net/gallery/47760149/HDHQ-Ganzer-Manchester-by-the-Sea-Film-Stream-Deutsch

  37. Pingback: https://www.behance.net/gallery/47760915/Ganzer-Ritter-Rost-2-Das-Schrottkomplott-Film-Deutsch

  38. Pingback: http://telegra.ph/HD-4K-Ganzer-Personal-Shopper-Film-Stream-Deutsch-Online-01-22

  39. Pingback: http://telegra.ph/FullHD-Ganzer-xXx-Die-Ruckkehr-des-Xander-Cage-Film-Stream-Deutsch-01-22

  40. Pingback: http://telegra.ph/HD-1080px-Ganzer-xXx-Die-Rckkehr-des-Xander-Cage-Film-Stream-Deutsch-01-22

  41. Pingback: hgh peptides for sale

  42. Pingback: procure anavar

  43. Pingback: mac select sheer pressed powder mineralize foundation loose nc colors wholesale

  44. Pingback: cheapest madden 17 coins mobile coins buy

  45. Pingback: nike baltimore ravens 92 haloti ngata limited black impact 2013 super bowl nfl jerse

  46. Pingback: Top pokemon go rare pokemon Site

  47. Pingback: cheap Dofus Touch Kamas

  48. Pingback: Albion Online gold

Comments are closed.